SW Laws

Home » Education » Should Witness ‘Flipping’ Be Illegal? — via Timothy T. Brock

Should Witness ‘Flipping’ Be Illegal? — via Timothy T. Brock

Issues Pending:

Archives

FindLaw Blotter - The FindLaw Crime and Criminals Blog

 

Should Witness ‘Flipping’ Be Illegal?

Even if you’re not a criminal defense attorney, watching a couple episodes of “Law and Order” will probably introduce you to the concept of police and prosecutors going after “small fish” in order to get the “big fish,” criminally speaking. This process involves lower level suspects or defendants exchanging testimony against higher level targets for lighter sentences or immunity.

The practice of flipping has become especially prominent in the investigation headed Robert Mueller looking into possible collusion between Russia and the Donald Trump presidential campaign. In fact, in the wake of news that Trump longtime lawyer and “fixer” Michael Cohen would be cooperating with federal prosecutors, the president decried the practice of witness flipping, claimed it encourages criminal defendants to unfairly “make up stories,” and asserted that “it almost ought to be illegal.”

Flipping may have its issues, but should it be outlawed?

The Force of Flipping

Much of the incentive to cooperate with law enforcement comes from the amount of power and discretion prosecutors have in determining both criminal charges and the possible sentences for convictions or guilty pleas. As criminal defense attorney Ken White pointed out at the Washington Post, “Federal prosecutors could flip Cohen because they had broad discretion to charge him with dozens of crimes or none; they alone decided how sweet a deal to offer and how ugly the alternative was.”

When faced with myriad possible criminal charges and years or decades behind bars (not to mention days and nights in jail until their case is resolved), defendants often feel they have little option but to give prosecutors any information they can, even if that information isn’t always accurate.

It doesn’t help that many of those targeted for flipping lack the financial resources to mount an adequate defense, and public defenders, too, are often underfunded and overworked. The choice of whether to flip or stay quiet and fight criminal charges is, more often than not, no choice at all.

Running on Flipping and Reform

“The criminal justice system,” White asserts, “runs on flipping defendants. If we want fairness for both the cooperating defendants and the people they implicate — if we want faith in the results — we need serious reform.”

Reform will almost certainly not include President Trump’s suggestion that flipping be outlawed, better funding for criminal defense and more transparency and consistency in charging and sentencing can be positive steps to, if not eliminating flipping, ensuring fairness for both those offering evidence against other criminal targets and those against whom that evidence will be used.

Related Resources:

via Should Witness ‘Flipping’ Be Illegal? — timothytbrock

Recent Posts: SW Laws

Can a Video be used as a Will? via Texas Estate and Probate Law

This column first appeared in the San Antonio Express News and other Hearst Newspapers on February 18, 2019. Dear Mr. Premack: My grandmother while in ICU stated that she wanted all she owned including her house to go to me and my bother in law. This was caught on cell phone video. She was later […] […]

Experiencing a Financial hardship?

A WAGE GARNISHMENT OR INCOME WITHHOLDING CAN BE CHALLENGED BY REQUESTING A HEARING UNDER 45 CFR 32.5. IF YOU WERE FIRED, OR HAVE SOME TYPE OF DISABILITY YOU CAN FILE A FINANCIAL HARDSHIP UNDER 45 CFR PART 32.9 § 32.9 Financial hardship. (a) A debtor whose wages are subject to a withholding order may, at any time, request […]

Purdue Pharma Maker of OxyContin agrees to Settlement in Oklahoma via WHNT.com

OKLAHOMA CITY (AP) — The maker of OxyContin and the company’s controlling family agreed Tuesday to pay a groundbreaking $270 million to Oklahoma to settle allegations they helped create the nation’s deadly opioid crisis with their aggressive marketing of the powerful painkiller. It is the first settlement to come out of the recent coast-to-coast wave […]

Duty to Protect / Correct Utilizing a Universal Standard of Principles (Part Two)

Originally posted on Anthony's Admin Law Blog:
After determining that the duty is triggered, we must determine what that duty entails. That leads to two questions: where does this situation fall on the spectrum of fairness and, depending on where it falls, what does that translate into in terms of specific procedures that must…

More on Wordpress

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Blog:: Forensic Files

Factors Affecting The Intensity Of Poisoning via Forensic’s blog

Factors Affecting The Intensity Of Poisoning Forms of Poison Intensity of poison Methods Of Administration By @forensicfield Introduction The resultant of poisoning depends on many factors. There are number of reasons which can affect intensity of poisoning are further explained, such as; Dose. Time of intake Way of taking Environmental factors, etc. Dose Amount of the […]

Biometrics — Forensic’s blog

INTRODUCTION The term “biometrics” is derived from the Greek words “bio” (life) and “metrics” (to measure). Biometrics is the technical term for body measurements and calculations. Biometrics is the measurement and statistical analysis of people’s unique physical and behavioral characteristics. Biometrics allows a person to be identified and authenticated based on a set of recognizable […]

Intro to Fingerprints via Forensic’s blog

Fingerprints- An Introduction Jan 29, 2019 Class characteristics Classification of fingerprints Galton system Henry classification Individual characteristic By @forensicfield INTRODUCTION Everything we touched, leave behind our unique impression on it, which is Our fingerprints. No two people have exactly the same fingerprints. Even identical twins, with identical DNA, have different fingerprints. Fingerprint identification also known as […]